EVA Interlayers in Hardened Facades

Evaluating Alternate Materials for Design of Blast Resistant Glazing

Overview

Abstract

Explosions can result in very high loads of extremely short durations. Protective design to mitigate the effects of blast loading requires façade hardening, which includes special considerations for glazing. Hardened systems may require specialized design skills or the use of advanced design software to provide solutions that will be effective in protecting building occupants by ensuring catastrophic structural or component failures do not occur. Explosions are an extreme load, typically requiring glazing to be designed to accommodate permanent damage. The focus of design is to control costs while protecting building occupants. During an explosion, glass can shatter and send high velocity shards into occupied space. To mitigate this hazard, it is common to utilize laminated glazing panels, which consist of flexible interlayer(s) sandwiched between multiple layers of glass. The interlayer exhibits ductile response to blast loads, allowing displacement while retaining fragments. Polyvinyl butyral (PVB) is the most common film interlayer utilized for blast resistance. However, ethylene-vinyl acetate (EVA) is widely available and is a potential alternative to PVB.

This paper summarizes the basic protective design principles utilized for the selection of glazing layups and highlights a recently completed multiyear effort to assess the relative efficacy of EVA-laminated glazing panels to resist blast loads. This effort involved interlayer material characterization, shock tube testing and open-air blast testing of laminated glazing panels with EVA and PVB interlayers. Results indicated that the EVA films tested exhibited similar qualitative and quantitative responses under dynamic loading conditions. While EVA holds promise for inclusion in hardened facades, care must be taken in implementation to effectively harness its protective capabilities. Findings from this effort were used to derive recommendations for the inclusion of EVA in facades designed to resist blast loading. These recommendations, as well as possible extensions of this effort, are highlighted.


Authors

Photo of Nicholas Oberts, PE

Nicholas Oberts, PE

Associate Principal

Karagozian & Case, Inc.

oberts@kcse.com

Photo of Mark K. Weaver, PE, SE

Mark K. Weaver, PE, SE

Principal

Karagozian & Case, Inc.

weaver@kcse.com

Photo of Phillip Benshoof, PE

Phillip Benshoof, PE

Physical Security Engineer

US Department of State Bureau of Diplomatic Security

BenshoofPC@state.gov


Keywords

Paper content

Introduction

Explosions, whether accidental or intentional, can result in very high loads of extremely short duration. Protective design against blast loading requires hardening of building systems, including glazing. As explosions

Access Restricted

Footnotes

Access Restricted

Acknowledgements

Access Restricted

Rights and Permissions

[1] Federal Emergency Management Agency, Primer for Design of Commercial Buildings to Mitigate Terrorist Attacks, 2003.

[2] H. Domininghaus, Kunststoffe - Eigenschaften und Anwendungen (Plastics - Properties and Applications, 5th Edition), Berlin: Springer-Verlag, 2012.

[3] M. J. Lowak, "Shock Tube Testing of EVA Laminated Glass," Baker Engineering and Risk Consultants, Inc., San Antonio, TX, 29 November 2022.

[4] M. K. Weaver, E. Kjolsing, l. Abdul Hadi and C. M. Newberry, "Construction Specification Guidance for EVA-Laminated Glazing Used in Blast Protection Designs: Results from Blast Tests of EVA-Laminated Glazing Panels," Karagozian & Case, Inc., Glendale, CA, TR-22-26, 29 November 2022.

[5] GSA-TS01-2003, "Standard Test Method for Glazing and Window Systems Subject to Dynamic Overpressure Loadings," U.S. General Services Administration, 1 January 2003.

[6] WINGARD Professional Edition (PE), Version 6.1, Applied Research Associates, Inc., September 2018.

[7] "Window Glazing Analysis Response & Design (WINGARD) - Technical Manual," Applied Research Associates, Inc., Vicksburg, MS (FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY), March 2020.

[8] ASTM F2912-17, "Standard Specification for Glazing and Glazing Systems Subject to Airblast Loadings," ASTM International, West Conshohocken, PA, 2017.

Access Restricted

Author Comments

Access Restricted